All Hanns on Deck
HomeTrips & RatesGalleryReviewsReportsTarget SpeciesMeet the Captain

Learn More

My Trips

Key Largo Evening Yellowtail Fishing Adventure

  • Published Date: October 17, 2025
  • Fishing
  • Key Largo
  • $600 - $1,250 price range

Summary

Join us for a laid-back evening of Yellowtail Snapper fishing off Key Largo's reefs. We'll head out at 6 PM, just as the sun starts to dip and the fish get active. Our local captain knows these waters like the back of his hand, so you're in for some steady action as night falls. The boat's got room for 4, making it perfect for families or small groups looking to unwind after a hot day. As we cruise the calm evening waters, you'll get to experience the reef coming to life. It's a great chance to hook into some tasty fish for dinner while soaking in the coastal scenery. The cooler temps and gentle evening vibe make for ideal fishing conditions. Whether you're an experienced angler or just starting out, this 3-hour trip offers a relaxing way to cap off your day in the Keys.
Key Largo Evening Yellowtail Fishing Adventure

Sunset Snapper Action

previous-image
Gag Grouper caught while fishing in FL

Massive Grouper landed off Key Largo!

Three people fishing in FL

Mahi and Tuna catch with All Hanns On Deck in Key Largo!

Four people fishing for an Atlantic Sailfish in FL

Swordfish catch offshore in Key Largo!

Two anglers fishing in the warm waters of Key Largo

Mahi catch day at All Hanns On Deck in Key Largo!

A fishing trip in FL

Wahoo caught offshore in Key Largo!

Four anglers with a successful fishing trip in Key Largo

Family Mahi catch with All Hanns On Deck in Key Largo!

4 Longfin Yellowtail fish caught while fishing in FL

Grouper lineup at All Hanns On Deck in Key Largo!

Two people fishing on the beach in Key Largo

Massive Grouper catch in Key Largo!

Bonnethead Shark caught while fishing in FL

Amberjack and Grouper haul in Key Largo!

7 black grouper in FL

Grouper catch day at All Hanns On Deck in Key Largo!

Gag Grouper caught while fishing in FL

Massive Grouper landed off Key Largo!

Three people fishing in FL

Mahi and Tuna catch with All Hanns On Deck in Key Largo!

Four people fishing for an Atlantic Sailfish in FL

Swordfish catch offshore in Key Largo!

Two anglers fishing in the warm waters of Key Largo

Mahi catch day at All Hanns On Deck in Key Largo!

A fishing trip in FL

Wahoo caught offshore in Key Largo!

Four anglers with a successful fishing trip in Key Largo

Family Mahi catch with All Hanns On Deck in Key Largo!

4 Longfin Yellowtail fish caught while fishing in FL

Grouper lineup at All Hanns On Deck in Key Largo!

Two people fishing on the beach in Key Largo

Massive Grouper catch in Key Largo!

Bonnethead Shark caught while fishing in FL

Amberjack and Grouper haul in Key Largo!

7 black grouper in FL

Grouper catch day at All Hanns On Deck in Key Largo!

Gag Grouper caught while fishing in FL

Massive Grouper landed off Key Largo!

Three people fishing in FL

Mahi and Tuna catch with All Hanns On Deck in Key Largo!

Four people fishing for an Atlantic Sailfish in FL

Swordfish catch offshore in Key Largo!

Two anglers fishing in the warm waters of Key Largo

Mahi catch day at All Hanns On Deck in Key Largo!

next-image

Key Largo's Sunset Yellowtail Bonanza

Ready for some evening action on the water? This 3-hour Key Largo reef trip is your ticket to prime-time yellowtail fishing as the sun dips below the horizon. We'll push off at 6 PM, just when the reef starts to buzz with activity. Our compact but capable vessel has room for 4, so grab your crew and let's hit those honey holes where the yellowtails are stacked up. As darkness falls, the bite heats up – and trust me, there's nothing like battling a feisty snapper under the stars. Whether you're looking to bend a rod with the family or score some fresh fillets for dinner, this trip delivers the goods without keeping you out all night. Just remember, your spot's locked in once you book, so choose wisely!

Evening Reef Rundown

Picture this: You're cruising out as the day's heat fades, the water's smooth as glass, and Key Largo's shoreline starts twinkling in the distance. That's the setting for our evening yellowtail hunt. We'll anchor up on some prime reef spots where these tasty snappers gather to feed. The beauty of fishing this time of day? Less boat traffic, cooler temps, and fish that are ready to chow down. Your captain's been doing this for years, so he knows exactly where to drop lines for the best shot at filling the cooler. Expect a laid-back vibe, but be ready for bursts of action when schools of yellowtail move through. It's the perfect mix of relaxation and rod-bending fun.

Tactics for Twilight Tails

Alright, let's talk strategy. We'll be using light tackle setups – think spinning reels with 15-20 lb test line. The key to yellowtail success is a stealthy approach. We'll set up a chum slick to bring the fish in close, then use small hooks and light leaders to fool these sharp-eyed snappers. You might be tossing out live shrimp, chunks of ballyhoo, or even small jigs. The real trick is in the presentation – a slow, natural drift of your bait is what seals the deal. As it gets darker, we'll switch to using lights to attract bait and bring in the yellowtails. It's a game of patience and finesse, but when you feel that telltale tap-tap-zip of a yellowtail taking off with your bait, you'll be hooked for life.

Target Species Lowdown

Yellowtail Snapper are the stars of this show, and for good reason. These golden-striped beauties are some of the tastiest fish in the Keys, with firm, white flesh that's killer on the grill or in ceviche. They typically run 1-3 pounds, but we sometimes hook into 4-5 pounders that'll give you a real workout on light tackle. Yellowtails are known for their speed and tendency to make quick runs, so stay on your toes! They school up on the reef edges, especially as night falls, which is why our evening trips are timed just right. The best part? They're a sustainable choice, so you can feel good about putting a few in the box for dinner.

While we're targeting yellowtails, don't be surprised if we tangle with some other reef residents. Mutton Snapper often crash the party, and these bruisers can push 10 pounds or more. They're less common but pack a serious punch when hooked. Muttons have a distinctive pink coloration and a black spot near the tail – spot one in the chum slick, and you're in for a treat. They tend to be solitary and warier than yellowtails, so landing one is a real trophy.

Why Anglers Keep Coming Back

Folks love our evening trips for a bunch of reasons. First off, it's a chance to see the Keys in a different light – literally. As the sun sets, the water takes on this amazing glow, and the first stars start to pop out. It's pretty magical stuff. Then there's the fishing itself. Evening trips often produce steadier action than daytime outings, especially in the warmer months. You're not baking in the sun, and the fish seem more willing to play. Plus, there's something about reeling in dinner under the moonlight that just feels special. It's a low-key adventure that delivers big on both the fun and tasty fronts.

Time to Lock In Your Lines

So, what do you say? Ready to trade the usual evening routine for some rod-bending action on the reef? Our Key Largo evening yellowtail trips are a local favorite for good reason. You get prime-time fishing, cooler temps, and a shot at some of the best-eating fish in the Keys. Whether you're a seasoned angler or just looking for a fun night out with the family, this trip fits the bill. Remember, we've only got room for 4, so don't wait too long to book. The yellowtails are out there waiting – let's go introduce ourselves!

Learn more about the animal

Mutton Snapper

Mutton Snapper (Lutjanus analis) Fish Description

Mutton snappers have an olive color that progresses from a dark to light tone from top to bottom. Its distinguishing features are the blue lines below and behind their eyes with the presence of a small black spot on both sides. The anal fin and dorsal fin’s rear edge are pointed, while the tail fin is rounded. This type of fish can most often be confused with the lane snapper. The tips to distinguish mutton snappers from lane snappers are the small blue streaks on the face and the anal and dorsal fins pointedness.

 

Mutton Snapper Diet

The diet of the mutton snapper changes throughout its lifespan. As larvae, the mutton snapper feeds on plankton near the surface of the water. As it matures and grows, it moves onto the shallow grass beds and takes in larger plankton to small animals. Once the mutton snapper is an adult, it will consume fish, shrimp, crabs, octopus, squid, and snails. It has no specific time for feeding, as it nourishes itself both day and night picking food items throughout the entire day.

 

Mutton Snapper Size

Adult mutton snappers can become quite a large fish, that can reach up to the length of 37 inches, however, most don’t go beyond 20 inches. The weight best recognized and recorded for this species is 34 pounds.

 

Interesting Facts About the Mutton Snapper

  • Mutton snappers are an extremely prized fish, especially game fish by saltwater anglers. Nice fighters, as they are often called, relative to the different snappers, so they are more durable to land on a lighter deal.
  • The mutton snapper is recognized more for its love for swimming in sandy areas. If the snapper stays within the more sandy areas, their colors will change from their pinkish color to a more greyish tone on their bodies. 
  • Mutton snappers, particularly adult muttons, are usually solitary so they are most often seen in smaller groups.

 

Mutton Snapper - Fishing Techniques

Mutton snappers are easy to catch, but some skill is still required. And that the presentation of the bait is of great importance! Only use the freshest bait and a light sinker to keep it still down there. The rough state of the water and slow bobbing movements will be necessary to compensate for the movements of the waters. A knocker rig or a jig to let the bait float in the current is also a good alternative to try. 

When fishing for mutton snappers in shallow waters, a good tip would be to let the bait drift in the chum slick on weight or a very low weight on a knocker rig, because those mutton snappers would love this! And chumming is also very good to get them to the surface, where you can try for flies or jigs. 

Once the mutton realizes it has been fooled, it will try and run along the ocean floor or get back into the structure. The best confidence booster to know when you’ve caught a mutton snapper is the moment you’re looking down and through the clear blue water and see pink. When that tinge of pink grows bigger as it nears the surface, that is when you need to bring it in and then lead the fish smoothly into your fish box. 

 

Mutton Snapper Habitat & Distribution

They are particularly widespread within the Caribbean, inhabiting reef environments. The mutton snapper is a common snapper species from Florida to South America. Occasionally, it can reach as far north as Massachusetts and south as southeastern Brazil, though these are rare occurrences. Mutton snappers can often be discovered from depths going from 82 to 295 ft, but most frequently in between 130 to 230 ft.

Muttons can be found inshore near reefs and along mangroves. Often, they are prevalent along inlets, where there is a good amount of tidal flow. But the fish can also be found along nearshore reef areas, where they tend to congregate just outside of extreme rock/reef formations in the sand. 

The adult mutton snappers tend to be more present in areas with rock or coral, whereas the younger adolescent fish happen to be in sandy habitats with weed progressive in the area.

Mutton Snapper

About the All Hanns on Deck

Company vehicle

Vehicle Guest Capacity: 4

Manufacturer Name: Yamaha

Maximum Cruising Speed: 37

Number of Engines: 2

Horsepower per Engine: 200

As the sun dips low over Key Largo, you'll slip out onto calm waters for an evening of yellowtail snapper fishing. This 3-hour trip kicks off at 6 PM, letting you take advantage of prime fishing conditions after sunset. Your local captain will guide you to the best reef spots, where the bite picks up as darkness falls. With space for up to 4 guests, it's an ideal outing for families or small groups looking to unwind and hopefully catch dinner. The cooler evening air makes for a pleasant experience as you cast lines and enjoy the coastal scenery. Whether you're an experienced angler or new to fishing, you'll appreciate the steady action and expert guidance. Remember, your catch could end up on your plate – there's nothing quite like the satisfaction of reeling in your own fresh seafood dinner.
All Hanns on Deck

Follow Us

FacebookInstagram

Navigate

Home

Trips & Rates

Gallery

Reviews

Reports

Target Species

Meet the Captain

FAQ

Contact Us

FEATURED

Fishing Season

Things To Do

Fishing License

Evening Catch

Offshore Fun

Reef Reeling

Key Largo Haul

Key Largo Reel

Reel in adventure with All Hanns On Deck Fishing Charters in Key Largo! Experience unforgettable deep sea fishing and family-friendly charters with a true local captain. Book your trip today and make memories that last long after you’re off the boat!

More about All Hanns on Deck

© Copyright 2025. All rights reserved.

Powered by Guidesly

Privacy Policy

Sitemap